Gator Creek Estates Sarasota – Luxury Homes with Acreage

 

Gator Creek Estates

Luxury Gated Community • Equestrian & Golf Lifestyle • Sarasota, FL

About the Community

Located near Myakka State Park, Gator Creek Estates is a private, deed-restricted enclave covering over 500 acres just east of I‑75, off Bee Ridge Extension. This exclusive Sarasota neighborhood features 69 custom estate homes on 5–10 acre parcels (average ~6.5 acres), many with barns and fencing. Architectural styles harmonize with the natural landscape, offering residents unmatched privacy and connection to nature. Wildlife is abundant, with sightings of wild turkeys, deer, quail, eagles, bobcats, wild hogs, and otters.

Equestrian & Golf Lifestyle

• Zoned for horses with community bridle trail (currently uncleared, HOA approval needed to restore)
• Gator Creek Golf Club: private, men-only, 250 members, 18-hole par-72 course by Joe Lee, renovated by Ron Garl in 2011; membership optional for homeowners

Location & Lifestyle

• ~14 miles to Downtown Sarasota
• ~15 miles to Gulf Coast beaches (Siesta Key, Lido Key)
• 1 mile to Publix Shopping Plaza
• Adjacent to Myakka State Park
• Rural atmosphere, gated nightly for security

Real Estate & Market

• Lot sizes: 5–10 acres (avg. ~6.5 acres)
• Home sizes: 1,500–8,000+ sq ft
• Prices (2025): $1.5M–$4.5M+

HOA & Community Governance

• Annual fee: $1,135 (common areas, maintenance)
• One-time closing fee: $10,000 capital improvement assessment
• Bridle trails: present but uncleared, require HOA vote for funds

For details, visit the Gator Creek Estates Improvement Association.

Flood Zone Notice

⚠ Some sections lie within FEMA flood zones. Buyers are advised to verify flood status for any property of interest.

Schools

Check specific school zoning with the official tool: Sarasota County School Zone Locator

Wildlife & Natural Environment

Enjoy abundant native wildlife, shaded bridle paths, and old-growth trees—perfect for nature lovers and equestrian enthusiasts alike.

Clark Road (SR 72) Road Expansion

The Florida Department of Transportation (FDOT) is conducting a PD&E Study on a 3.4-mile segment of SR 72 (Clark Road) from east of I‑75 to Lorraine Road. Plans include widening to 4 lanes, adding shared-use paths, stormwater improvements, and enhanced safety features. The study is set to complete by late 2025; construction timelines are forthcoming. Learn more at the FDOT SR 72 Project Page. For more details, visit the official FDOT project page: 👉 Clark Road (SR 72) PD&E Study DetailsThis infrastructure improvement will enhance connectivity while preserving Gator Creek’s serene and private setting.

Map & Directions

Gator Creek Estates, Sarasota, FL 34241   Interested in private tours or listings? Contact us today for expert insights into Gator Creek Estates—Sarasota’s premier equestrian and golf community.
Sorry we are experiencing system issues. Please try again.